About Us
Find Us
Contact Us

What's On


soul space

Prayer and
Bible Study

Prayer Diary

Pilgrim Way

Healing Ministry

Christian Resources

Information for Visitors


Photo Album

St Cuthbert
Celtic Way

The Church
The Organ
Stained Glass


Church Lettings

Society of Friends

Family History Searches


Christian Resources
Biblical Themes :
A Kindly Judgement

Cuthbert cross

Kindly Judgement

St Luke chapter 7, verse 36'Jesus went into the Pharisees house and took his place at the table.' 

And I'm sure you can't wait to do the same - to get to your house and take your place at the table for lunch! But if you can hold on for a moment, I'll tell you a story. 

Once upon a time, there was a man called Cosmo Gordon Lang. He was the Archbishop of Canterbury during the crisis of the Abdication of King Edward VIII and at the outbreak of the Second World War. He began his ministry as a curate in Leeds, and some fifty years later he told how  

. . . part of the district assigned to me was inhabited by homeless people of the lowest class living in common lodging-houses.  

In many of these lodging-houses the most elementary decencies of ordinary life and the restraints of what we call morality were unknown. Into one of them there came once a young man from the country, seeking work, ignorant of the pitfalls of the town, and in an advanced stage of consumption. When there, his illness overcame him and he was at death's door. Among the denizens of this lodging-house was a young 'woman who was a sinner.' She took pity on the homeless, friendless, dying lad, protected him, nursed him, paid for his few necessities by the earnings of her own manner of life. 

'As death drew near, knowing, as she told me, that he had been well brought up in the country, she came one night to me and asked me to see him. I did so then and for a day or two after, and was able to minister to him. When he died I committed his poor worn body to the earth and his soul to God. As I did so, I caught sight of the young woman who had befriended him standing alone at a distance. When all was over I asked her why she had not come nearer. This was her answer: 'I wouldn't let my black soul be near to spoil his white soul at its passing. 

Black soul! Surely whiter in her self-forgetting charity than many an outwardly respectable soul filled with jealousy or uncharitableness or the deadly sin of self-righteousness . . .   1 

Now doesn't that resonate tellingly with St Luke's story of Simon the Pharisee and that other 'woman who was a sinner'; and isn't Lang's kindly judgement on the woman a vibrant echo of Jesus' judgement on the woman in the Gospel story? She comes into Simon the Pharisee's house when he is giving a party at which Jesus is a guest. She bathes Jesus' feet with her tears, kisses them, and anoints them with ointment. Simon feels that Jesus' acceptance of such a display is not consistent with a prophet who comes from God: any prophet worth his salt would repudiate the woman's advances and expose her sinfulness. Jesus answers Simon's unspoken criticism with the parable of two debtors, which vividly makes the point that one who is forgiven much (the woman) is likely to respond more warmly than one who is forgiven little (Simon). 

Where does that leave Simon? He is, after all, a Pharisee, virtuous and respectable. There's not much in his life that needs to be forgiven. But is that really so? What about his uncharitableness, his lack of openness, his hard judgemental attitude towards this woman, his cold contempt for people of her kind? Are they not sins which need forgiveness every bit as much as this woman's openly deplorable behaviour? 

And what about the woman? When Simon condemns her as a sinner, no one contradicts him, no one speaks up for her: she doesn't even speak in her own defence; she knows she is morally reprehensible. But Jesus treats her with unquestioning acceptance and gentle understanding. He asks for no confession, seeks no expression of regret - and yet Jesus insists she is forgiven. Don't you find that striking? All our life we've been taught that without confession and repentance there can be no forgiveness. Yet here is a woman whom Jesus welcomes and accepts without penitence being either asked for or volunteered. 

What can it mean? Perhaps the woman has heard of Jesus as 'the friend of tax-collectors and sinners', and is irresistibly attracted to him by his lack of condemnation, his recognition that she and people like her are also God's children and also the recipients of his love. And so she responds to him with a warmth and a love which he unhesitatingly accepts. 

The question this raises for us is, 'Who are we like: Simon, or Jesus?' How do we treat people, not just people like the woman in the story, who have lost their way and are sunk in some sort of shame and disgrace; but people who are outsiders by their culture or creed, people who are vulnerable and exploited by society, people who are, well, just different from us? Do we treat them with criticism and censure or kindness and care? With Jesus, it was all kindness, all acceptance: he had a welcome for everybody. His followers are meant to show that same forbearance and forgiveness, that same courtesy and kindness, that same welcome and acceptance. 

We began this sermon with words from an Archbishop of Canterbury. We end it with words from another Archbishop of Canterbury, the present one, Justin Welby, who preached the sermon in Westminster Abbey at the Service for the 60th Anniversary of the Coronation. In the course of the sermon he said 

'. . . we see in the life of Jesus, (that) God's justice and mercy are perfectly joined, wisdom is unlimited, generosity is unstinting, and love pours out over the whole world in an overwhelming embrace that is offered universally and abundantly. 

We see all that in the life of Jesus, says the Archbishop; and he might well have added, we should see it, too, all that unstinting generosity, all that overwhelming love, in the life of all Jesus' followers - and that means in your life, and in mine. 

And now you have heard that message and absorbed that lesson you can go to your house and take your place at table and have your lunch!  

 1    Cosmo Lang Archbishop in War and Crisis Robert Beaken I. B. Tauris 2012 p. 27

Rev Charles Robertson , June 2013


For Website issues only, please contact :

For all Church or calendar related issues, please contact :

purple outline image of church
St Cuthbert's Parish Church. 5 Lothian Road. Edinburgh. UK. EH1 2EP

St Cuthbert's Church
soul space
Pilgrim Way

Podcasts / Recordings

{short description of image}
YouTube videos

{short description of image}
Church of Scotland blogs

St Cuthbert's Church